A dull thud in the distance
Header

German strength, French weakness

January 25th, 2012 | Posted by Aosher in Politics | Politics - EU

There is an old adage to the effect that the Franco-German relationship exists to both hide France’s weakness and obscure German strength.

Post-reunification, Germany has had an uneasy relationship with its own power. It remains a reluctant military power, much to the frustration of its allies in Washington, London and NATO; and in the EU it has preferred to wield it’s clout quietly, allowing France’s Nicholas Sarkozy to take the lead on promoting a “Merkozy” agenda while keeping its own arm-twisting activities behind closed doors. The one area in which Germany has been contend to exert itself has been economic. Ironically, the division and reunification of the country has left it less dependent on post-manufacturing industries and recession-hit developed markets than it’s big European stablemates, and its historic position as east and south Europe’s main creditor has been carefully mitigated by extraordinarily low levels of public, corporate an personal debt. An economy that was already reaping the capacity benefits of its long, slow process of reunification is ideally placed to maximise its gains from a weak global economy and its subsequent rebound.

France is another story. The global recession has been particularly cruel to France, exposing the gaps in its massively centralised, leveraged economy. Even Britain’s similarly sized and distributed market has fared better, partly thanks to the City of London’s cozy relationship with the money markets but also thanks to a perception that the UK, which has much more control over its own currency and spending, is better placed to affect a recovery. The recent downgrade of its bonds by S&P has also effectively ended he collective delusion that France could be at the political core of the Eurozone. What moral right does France have to lead when it is ultimately in the same firing line as Italy and Spain? It’s political authority was always borrowed, but now the transaction is compromised. The ideological core of the Euro is Germany, and always has been, but that is now explicit.

This is starting to show in practice. Over the last month Angela Merkel has been taking meetings with European leaders in private, to promote her agenda, bypassing the French altogether. In public both sides insist that nothings has changed, but tell-tale signs of status anxiety – familiar to those who have observed the Anglo-American relationship – have started to emerge from Paris.

There are both opportunities and risks here for Germany and the Eurozone. The risks are most obvious. A Europe led by Franco-German concord could maintain a veneer of consensus politics. Unbridled German leadership may will no longer have that figleaf, and public discontent at ECB-enforced austerity may take on a new form. The image of an assertive Germany remains politically sensitive in Europe, for reasons that feel anachronistic in Britain and America but which still strongly resonate in Poland and Hungary. And like it or not, Germany’s political class are curiously uncharasmatic by European standards. This sends a message about what the Germans look for in a leader, but makes the task of selling tough economic reform to the Greeks and Italians – who have a marked preference for flash in their leaders – more of an uphill struggle.

The opportunities, however, are massive. Germany’s self-imposed doctrine of consensus-led soft power has allowed it to recover both the position and the reputation that it has always traditionally enjoyed, but the extent to which it can help – now that it has surpassed its local rivals and remains the only identifiably big fish in a medium-sized pond (which is shrinking by the day) – is diminishing. Meanwhile, it commands vast production resources, an educated and mobile workforce, and all of the legal accouterments considered necessary for an emerging market make the big leap. It feels odd to be talking about Germany as if it were an emerging power, as its level of development greatly exceeds that of the likes of, say, Brazil or South Africa. But, at the head and the heart of the world’s largest common market, Germany has the potential – if harnessed properly – to parlay its current position into something much greater. It is not too big a claim to suggest that the 21st Century could as easily be German as Chinese.

The obstacles to this are great. Britain, France, Italy and Spain are as likely to obstruct German leadership as support it, although – as David Cameron’s abortive veto over changes to the Euro Stability Pact before Christmas demonstrates – mutual antipathies make them unlikely to oppose a German ascent in tandem. The bigger obstacle is that Germany largely does not perceive itself as a hegemon-in-waiting. But then, neither did America. What is interesting is that Germany has many of the qualities required, should the need arise.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 You can leave a response, or trackback.

2 Responses

  • innokenti says:

    I think you’re probably right. It would just be a shame if a lot of this was counteracted by a reactionary view of German leadership which I don’t see dissipating. However anachronistic it might feel in the UK, it will still be a large factor of public knee-jerk opinion.

  • Hentzau says:

    To be perfectly honest I’m not entirely sure it is that much of an anachronism in Britain — certainly not as far as the tabloids are concerned.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>